How to deal with fake and defamatory Google reviews

Adam Sapic Profile Pic
By Adam Šapić

When you are purchasing a product or service online, you most likely peruse the reviews before making your decision. According to a study by Podium, 93% of consumers say online reviews have an impact on their intent to purchase.

Business owners are very passionate about receiving accurate feedback from customers. In addition to using such feedback for marketing purposes, reviews also give an indication of how a business is performing.

Reviews are also considered to be a ranking factor, which influences your brand’s visibility in search engine result pages. Some publications such as Search Engine Journal reported that reviews were the most prominent local SEO ranking factor in 2017.

It’s no wonder, after putting in so much hard work that business owners melt into a pit of despair upon receiving either a fake or defamatory review. I have witnessed this on multiple occasions but there are solutions depending on the situation.

Without further ado, here are our recommendations on how to deal with both fake and defamatory Google reviews based upon our client experiences and how we guided them to a solution. Before I continue, it’s important to understand the golden rule.

Don’t let your emotions respond!

I understand that toxic reviews just make business owners want to scream the roof down. However, if you start responding with your emotions in full swing, it’s not going to do you any favours.

Imagine a prospective customer looking at your angry response. They could interpret it as being unprofessional because you are not keeping your cool. Furthermore, you may look guilty in the eyes of others because you are not responding in a collected and calm manner.

Prospects and customers don’t want to see a bitching match online. So if you really do feel like sending an angry response, sleep on it! You may feel better the next day and ready to respond in the best way possible. Aim to respond within 24 hours though.

Removing or deleting fake Google reviews

Fake reviews are particularly frustrating. You can spot them usually due to a suspicious username and profile pic, which also may be blank. Here’s an example left for one of our clients who delivers their services face-to-face.

Defamatory Google Review

There are multiple reasons why someone would do this. Perhaps it’s a competitor playing dirty or a disgruntled employee. It could be a customer who took things the wrong way after refusing to pay for a booked session that was cancelled at the last minute, which violates the client’s terms of service.

This review is quite alarming and instantly could damage the reputation of the business if not dealt with in the appropriate manner. So let’s go through the options.

Contact Google My Business

If the review directly violates Google’s review policy and terms of service then it’s worth contacting Google My Business, the team that is responsible for Google reviews. Click ‘Contact us’ in the top right and then you have an option for a call back after selecting ‘Customer reviews and photos’ and ‘Manage customer reviews’ from the menu.

Requesting call back from Google My Business

When talking to Google, it’s handy to have ready the clause of their terms or review policy that the offending review directly violates.

Be warned! The team from Google My Business may not accept your case even if the offending review directly violates their terms. Here’s an example explaining why. The call centre is based in India. After explaining that the above review falls under ‘Offensive content’ in the review policy, the agent, after performing a series of checks, informed me that the review does not violate their terms.

After explaining what ‘touchy’ and ‘feely’ means in the UK, the agent noted down my argument and informed me that the case would be sent to a specialist team who rejected our argument. It seems like the team in India aren’t aware of what certain terms mean in the UK.

If you fail the first time, it might be worth trying again later on. If you repeatedly fail to gain success using this method, move on to the next option.

Flagging a Google review

On desktop, you will see little flag icon next to the review.

How to flag a Google review on desktop

On mobile, tap the three dots and select ‘Report review’.

How to flag a Google review on mobile

Then enter your email and select the appropriate violation type using Google’s review policy as a guideline.

Report violation Google review policy

Now it’s time get support. Contact your clients, friends and family. Tell them what has happened and ask them to also flag the review. Send a step-by-step instruction to make it as easy as possible for them to help. You’d be surprised how others, especially clients will support your cause.

The more flags Google receives, the more likely they will take action and remove the review. Again, it’s worth noting that this option does not guarantee success. From our experience, it has worked for some and not for others but it’s still worth doing.

Submit a legal request of removal

After a time, if flagging does not work, you have the option of submitting a legal request of removal. Because Google asks you to cite specific provisions of law, you may wish to consider consulting an appropriate legal professional before submitting this request.

Responding to fake Google reviews

If all the above fails, or for whatever reason you want a quicker solution, the next option is to respond. Here is how I responded to the fake review detailed above.

How to respond to a fake Google review

Anyone looking at your reviews and seeing this response is more likely to view your brand favourably. Other gleaming feedback along with the fact that the offending review has a suspiciously fake name and no profile pic may work in your favour.

Keep your response objective and to the point or feel free to use the above as a template.

It’s important to note that sometimes, fake reviews do not leave any feedback as shown in this example.

How to respond to one star Google reviews

I have found it practically impossible to remove these reviews because, in Google’s eyes, the user is registering their genuine feedback using their star rating. The user also has used what looks like a genuine name. In this case, the best option is to respond.

Responding to defamatory or inaccurate Google reviews

Now, this requires a different strategy. A defamatory review contains inaccurate feedback left by an actual customer. They may use an alias account when leaving feedback. Usually, their feedback will help you identify which customer this relates to.

For the record, Google states the following in their review policy:

“Reviews are only valuable when they are honest and unbiased.”

Contacting Google and flagging the review may not be the best option; therefore, a response is required. To help you understand how to respond, I will use a situation that was presented to another client who is a psychotherapist.

After being presented with a dangerous situation, our client reported the incident to the relevant authorities. Our client has a legal obligation to do this, which is clearly communicated to the customer before any counselling sessions are delivered.

As a result the customer left an inaccurate and defamatory Google review.

Working with our client, their legal department and the regulatory authority, we drafted an email response informing the customer that their feedback violated Google’s review policy. We recommended they alter their feedback to represent what actually happened.

Our client’s customer then amended their review and removed all defamatory content. We then drafted a response for our client.

How to respond to a inaccurate or defamatory Google review

It’s inevitable that businesses will eventually receive negative reviews. However, so long as the feedback falls in line with Google’s review it’s not worth tearing your hair out. A concise and objective response is the best option.

Pump up your ratings!

If you do receive a negative review that you still think isn’t deserved, ask for more reviews! Contact your current and previous clients, suppliers and affiliates. Ask them for feedback. If you receive an influx of positive feedback, a prospective customer may disregard the negative review when engaging with your business. It also raises your average star rating.

Concluding thoughts

Asking for feedback and reviews on a regular basis is now considered a standard practice across all industries. Ensure that your business has an appropriate procedure for gathering feedback and managing your online reputation. If you require assistance, contact a specialist like UNIMETRICS.

Thank you to all of our clients who graciously allowed us to share their experiences.

Adam Sapic Profile Pic

Adam Šapić

Adam is the Digital Marketing Strategist at UNIMETRICS. He has worked with FTSE100 companies, large non-profits and small to medium progressive businesses. Adam is a website and data devotee, writer, designer, creator, strategic thinker and loves discussions, learning and sharing.

By signing up you are agreeing to our Privacy Policy.